I just tried Elta MD UV Physical. I tried it years ago and hated it. But I thought I'd give it another try. I think I like it! Definitely better for me than the MDsolarsciences one, which I find too greasy and heavy feeling. This one is less silicone-y, so you might not like it. It feels more like a moisturizer. It also doesn't pack quite the amount of zinc oxide as the MDSolarSciences. On the other hand, I find it much easier to spread and see where it is being applied. I also feel as though it comes out a bit more opaque, so with a powder over it, I could get away with it for my foundation layer on a light day.