The Mascara You Should NEVER Wear With Contact Lenses

September

The Mascara You Should NEVER Wear With Contact Lenses

Rebecca’s contact concern: I read at Consumer Reports.org that contact lens wearers should not use lash-extending mascaras because they contain microfibers that become trapped under the lens and scratch the cornea. What qualifies as a lash-extending mascara? Do the labels “lengthening” and “lash-extending” mean the same thing? Do they mean anything? If a mascara is labeled safe for contact lens wearers is it indeed safe?

The Left Brain’s cautionary contact connection:

Excellent question, Rebecca. I’m a big fan of Consumer Reports so I tracked down the article you referenced along with a few other resources. It turns out that there is a real reason for concern in this case.

Contact concern

After reading what Consumer Reports said I found another source, The Look You Like: Medical Answers to 400 Questions on Skin and Hair Care, that describes the basic problem: lash extenders consist of tiny synthetic fibers in a liquid base. When the liquid evaporates the fibers are left behind on the lashes, making them look longer. But as these fibers become loose they can stick get in your eye and become stuck to your contacts.

I found additional details in a 1985 New York Times article that quoted Dr. Oliver H. Dabezies Jr., a clinical professor of ophthalmology at Tulane Medical School. Dr. Dabezies specified that the synthetic fibers used in masacaras are actually nylon fibers. I thought it was interesting that he notes using cosmetics with soft contacts is particularly risky because those types of lenses “are like sponges that absorb everything, including mascara.” So soft lenses are prone to clouding due to absorbed bits of mascara while hard lenses can trap nylon fibers that can cause painful scratches which can lead to eye infections.

Safety testing

What about mascara that claims to be safe for contact-lens wearers? According to the article, “even these claims, however, do not indicate whether the products have been tested with all types of lenses. Maybelline’s mascaras, for example, though labeled ‘’safe with contact lenses,” were not tested with the new extended-wear lenses. Nor has Max Factor’s ”For Your Eyes Only” line.” I recognize that this article is a bit dated, but it does make me wonder if these companies have updated their testing.

Which brands contain nylon?

I did a quick search and found several brands that use Nylon-6 or Nylon-12.

Yves Saint Laurent MASCARA VOLUME EFFET FAUX CILS Luxurious Mascara

Volume.com mascara

The Body Shop mascara

Revlon Lash Fantasy Total Definition Primer & Mascara

You can do a quick check on your own brands by looking at the ingredient list for any chemicals that contain the term “nylon.”

The Beauty Brains bottom line

Based on what I’ve seen, if you wear contact lenses it might be wise to avoid using mascaras that contain nylon fibers. Product names like Longer Lash, Lush Lash, and Lash Lengthener, don’t really tell you very much, so to be safe you need to look at the ingredient list for any ingredient says “nylon.”

What do YOU think? Do you wear contacts? What kind of mascara do you use? Leave a lengthening comment for the rest of the Beauty Brains community.

14 Responses to “The Mascara You Should NEVER Wear With Contact Lenses”

Rebecca Says:

Thanks for answering my question, Left Brain.

I checked my Almay One Coat Lengthening mascara (labeled safe for contacts) and it does in fact contain Nylon-12. Almay One Coat Thickening does not appear to contain nylon though, so I’m going to pick that up the next time I buy a tube.

Thanks again.
Zhariel Says:

I’m currently using Rimmel Eye Magnifier Eye Opening Mascara, Extreme Black. After checking the ingredients:
Water Aqua ,
Paraffin ,
Beeswax Cera Alba ,
Stearic Acid ,
PVP ,
Copernicia Cerifera Carnauba Wax Cera Carnauba ,
C18-36 Acid Triglyceride ,
Triethanolamine ,
Lecithin ,
Acrylates Copolymer ,
Panthenol ,
Propylene Glycol ,
Polyvinyl Alcohol ,
Phenoxyethanol ,
Methylparaben ,
Tocopheryl Acetate ,
Talc ,
Propylparaben ,
Benzyl Alcohol ,
Simethicone ,
Iron Oxides CI 77491 – CI 77492 – CI 77499 ,
Carmine CI 75470 ,
Chromium Hydroxide Green CI 77289 ,
Chromium Oxide Greens CI 77288 ,
Mica CI 77019 ,
Titanium Dioxide CI 77891 ,
Ultramarines CI 77007

I don’t see nylon listed.
Would anything else in there be bad for contact wearers?
anactoria Says:

I’ve been having a lot of problems with my contacts just of late, even scratched one eye. I took my contacts out (now I’m breaking out since I’m allergic to nickel =( ) I’m still getting things in my eyes, but it isn’t contact catastrophe like before.

So, I think I have my answer. I use Rimmel’s ‘NYLON IN YOUR EYES MASCARA’ or something like that. Sephora lists ingredients don’t they? Anyone have some recs for a good, lush, non-clumpy mascara?
chipotle91 Says:

I use Neutrogena Clean Lash Tint and I’ve never had any problems with it. I have not looked at the ingredients, and it doesn’t do a lot other than darken, but it is the only thing I’ve found that NEVER smudges and doesn’t flake off into my contacts or anything else. An eyelash curler and a couple of light coats make my lashes look pretty good.
Chic Clicks: The Best Of This Weeks Beauty Blogs | The Beauty Brains Says:

[...] The Beauty Brains lash out at the mascara you should NEVER wear with contact lenses. [...]
This Week in Style Blogging » Smarter Fashion Blog Says:

[...] The Beauty Brains lash out at the mascara you should NEVER wear with contact lenses. [...]
SeenON! Blog » Blog Archive » SeenON! Weekly Web Roundup September 19, 2008 Says:

[...] StyleBakery.com StyleBakery has the scoop on the five pieces every stylish girl should own. The Beauty Brains The Beauty Brains lash out at the mascara you should NEVER wear with contact lenses. [...]
Jennifer Says:

Thanks for this information – who knew?? I’m going to check all of my mascaras now!
Chic Clicks: The Best Of This Weeks Beauty Blogs | Beauty Secrets Blog Says:

[...] Beauty Brains lash out at the mascara you should NEVER wear with contact lenses. Posted in The better you RSS 2.0 | Trackback | Comment Get post updates via emailEnter your [...]
Chic Clicks: The Best Of This Weeks Beauty Blogs | 1800blogger Says:

[...] The Beauty Brains lash out at the mascara you should NEVER wear with contact lenses. [...]
Shannon Says:

I just checked the ingredients for Too Faced Lash Injection Black mascara, and it looks like there’s no nylon. Yay!
MizzJ Says:

Great article! I’m going to check all my mascaras asap now!
kikay exchange » Blog Archive » All About Eyes Says:

[...] *Sources: Shine and The Beauty Brains. [...]
Marina Says:

My Maybelline Define-a-Lash in the green bottle lists rayon as an ingredient. Is that the same as nylon fibers?