Rimmel has a waterproof pencil that works well for me. I’m not too pickey when it comes to pencils to tightline though. I find it doesn’t irritate or get into my eyes, lining the bottom waterline is worse in that aspect for me.
When tightlining I try to focus on just the lash line avoiding the waterline as much as possible.
Just a side note, if you’re doing this frequently try to learn how to do it without pulling your upper lid up. You’ll just be asking for wrinkles and skin sag.
Hello Sarah, saw this on Wayne Goss’ youtube channel which could be interesting about a new method of tightlining/lining called “the most amazing makeup tip you will ever learn” (in case the link below doesn’t work).Tell me if it works for you.