Learn what is really real, in an industry full of fake › Forums › Ask the Beauty Brains › The Ordinary
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
November 26, 2016 at 7:40 pm #96686PeterMemberAllergy can be one of the problems with propylene glycol, but the main problem is its irritation potential which can occur at concentrations as low as 1-2% (link). In that regard, I totally disagree with Paula Begoun (she rates it as good). Pentylene Glycol, Hexylene Glycol may be somewhat irritating as well, but not as much as propylene glycol.This book explains a bit more in detail what damage phototoxic plant extracts do inside your cells, link, p634.You still don’t believe me that the Buffet (or matrixyl) doesn’t contain copper A peptide isn’t automatically a copper peptide, the Buffet of The Ordinary contains peptides bound to palmitic acid (in stead of copper). Deciem does have copper peptide serums, but there’s no problem with combining The Ordinary Buffet with the Ascorbic Acid because it doesn’t contain copper. It is true in general that vitamin C doesn’t absorb very well, that’s why you need to use such extreme high amounts for it to be effective. But 23% anhydrous vitamin C will definitively give you the anti-aging benefits of Vitamin C. And also consistent use will give you kind of a reservoir of Vitamin C in skin. I just received all the other Vitamin C serums of The Ordinary. The 23% Ascorbic Acid is really something for PM use, I think its very good, but I like to use multiple products so then a derivative might be better.The Moogoo Super Vitamin C serum looks good, squalane is also a photoprotective ingredient. Although its more expensive than The Ordinary 20% Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate. And I’m wondering about the 25% Tocopherol, if that’s true, it really is too high, Tocopherol is fine anywhere between 1-2%, but any higher can be detrimental to skin. I guess the A’kin contains a rather low percentage of Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate, also it contains the irritant Rosemary Leaf Extract.November 27, 2016 at 12:15 am #96687preciousiaMember
>I totally disagree with Paula Begoun (she rates it as good).
agreed. i disagree with PB here. Don’t like Propylene Glycol!what about butylene glycol? i see that a lot in my skincare…wow.. .what a nice book.. i have bookmarked it to read later! yay! just scanned the index and its covers so much!I was thinking about The Ordinary buffet and the vitamin C this morning and i believe you… lol i think i just got confused for a while… Ascorbic acid is water soluble.. so that reservoir can’t be that long right? Drunk elephant says we need only apply vitamin C (theirs at least) once every 2 days.agreed with you about Vitamin C 23%!! i will purchase the other derivatives … give this cheapie a miss… also because i layer many products.is it ok to use Deciem’s NIOD Copper Amino Isolate Serum 1% + vitamin C derivative (layering one after another?)Moogoo has 25% Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate!! not Vitamin E… did i mistype that. oppsI thought rosemary is a good antioxidant… really an irritant? it doesn’t irritate me tho.can’t wait to hear your review on the other Ordinary vitamin C serums.November 27, 2016 at 12:17 pm #96699PeterMemberI’m not completely sure about the other glycols. I’ve been researching them for quite a while now, but the information is scarce. There are so many different glycols, certainly Propylene Glycol is the smallest molecule. But Butylene Glycol, Pentylene Glycol and Hexylene Glycol are also small.
According the safety tests all glycols are safe and not irritating at the typical concentration at which they are used. But according my dermatologist Propylene Glycol has been an issue since decades, it can be irritating for skin at concentrations as low as 1-2%. So well, I really would like to know the truth about the other glycols. Glycols are used very often these days, because they also function as preservatives. So companies can formulate “preservative free” products this way.November 27, 2016 at 12:33 pm #96700PeterMemberI’ve read that Vitamin C can still be found in skin after 2-5 days after stopping the vitamin c regimen. So using vitamin C daily only at night must certainly give you the benefits.
According Deciem it’s no problem with combining the NIOD Copper Amino Isolate with one of the vitamin C derivatives. Because the derivatives are not unstable, and are formulated at a higher pH (more like your skin), it doesn’t influence the copper. Although you have to wait a minute or so with the ethyl-ascorbic acid from NIOD.The Moogoo does contain 25% tocopherol look at the picture of the packaging…25% tocopherol is really to high unfortunately..With many photosensitive/phototoxic plant extract you don’t see immediate irritation, but as explained in the book and links I sent, it does cause cellular damage and it breaks down collagen. Companies want you to believe that the very special active they use, is the best in the world, while in reality there is hardly any science proving it’s efficiency let alone its safety. Personally I think it is very important to stick to the well researched, safe, non-irritating ingredients….if you look at it this way… exactly what The Ordinary does (vitamin C, niacinamde, vitamin A etc).I’ve asked The Ordinary about their very inconvenient “oxidizing” dropper packaging, this is what they claim:The stability of our products and formulas is tested in our lab prior to be on the market. Airless packaging, when unncessary is simply a marketing approach.Our stability under UV, air and heat has shown a near-zero effect on product! We are confident that our packaging does not compromise the product’s effect.About the Advanced Retinoid 2%, both types of Retinoid used in this product are far more advanced that Retinol and stable in case of air exposure. In fact, pure prescription retinoic acid is genereally supplied in tubes as there’s no concern for degredation in air exposure. The stability of our products and formulas is tested in our lab prior to be on the market. Same is applicable to EGCG and Vitamin C. Really airless packaging, when unncessary is simply a marketing approach!With that being said, we also formulate most of our products at very low viscosities to allow for optimum absorption into the skin! With such low viscosities, airless pumps are not the ideal choice as the pressure causes a harsh spurt to come out and splash in your hand. Regular air (pump) systems have the same problem to a lesser extent. The other alternative is truly very narrow nozzle tubes which wastes about 15% of the product that cannot get out at the end. As a result of this position, our most complex formulations are in dropper systems so we don’t have to sacrifice our low-viscosity formulations and our customers won’t have to worry about wasting product!
The Niacinamide shouldn’t be used in conjunction with the Vitamin C Suspension because the formulation suspension and potency is so high. You can use Niacinamide with any other product, such as the Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate, Ascorbyl Glucoside, Matrixyl and Magnesium Ascorbyl Phosphate. Niacinamide is completely safe to use with C25 from Hylamide and Ethylated L-Ascorbic Acid 30% Network from NIOD.November 27, 2016 at 4:12 pm #96706PeterMemberAlthough the respond of the ordinary is quite logical, they’re not going to say anything negative about themselves of course. Even if the products were unstable, they wouldn’t admit that. But if an airless pump is not necessary for the stability of the active ingredients, it indeed is only a marketing trick which the other companies play. I really don’t know, what to believe, Paula’s Choice doesn’t use many airless pumps either and claims to produce stable products. The Ordinary also put some of their products in bottles with UV-protective glass, if they didn’t care about stability at all, they wouldn’t bother doing that either.I must say looking at this interview with Brandon Truaxe, I can’t deny I think he is more focused on making money and expanding worldwide, than about formulating stable products. If a costumer is fine with dropper bottles, and only looks at the percentage of the active, and not at the other ingredients it’s fine with him I guess. But maybe I’m evil now It’s so hard for a consumer to know who is honest, and what the truth is, and there is so much controversy regarding stability of ingredients. I’m planning on reading more on Brandon, to get to know his motives. I have frequently met with Jetske Ultee, the founder of Uncover Skincare, and I must say I think she is quite honest about everything. She believes you can’t formulate with those kind of anti-oxidants if they are not packaged in airless pumps, but well, her own products are packaged airless, so there is a conflict of interest, could this be a marketing trick as well?Here’s a movie about their international shipping, I must admit it’s quite fast, about 4-5 days!November 27, 2016 at 5:54 pm #96708PeterMemberAlso if you want a complete routine with different actives, you need to buy multiple serums at The Ordinary, because every serum only has 1 or 2 actives. So in the end you are combining (diluting) the serums and all of them together might still cost around (9.80+5.90+17.70+6.80+14.80+6.70 = 61.70 euro), which is an average price for a high quality serum.I mean if you buy the Paula’s Choice 10% Niacinamide, you also get other actives (15 in total), although that serums costs around 63 dollars for 30mL and the Hyaluronic Acid Booster costs 69 dollars for 30 mL. The Resist Antioxidant Serum contains about 18 different actives, at a price of 38 dollars. The percentages are rather low at Paula’s Choice however. But I just thought a complete routine at The Ordinary is maybe not as expensive as other brands, but also not as cheap as you might think.So with my routine you have about 10 actives, at a price of 61.70 euro.Retinoid = 9.80Niacinamide+ Zn = 5.90Vitamin C = 17.70Hyaluronic Acid +B5 = 6.80Buffet (peptides+amino acids) = 14.80Caffeine+ EGCG = 6.70November 28, 2016 at 2:16 am #96711preciousiaMemberI agree with you on the integrity of the founder.with the ordinary… the sole actives allow me to do some self-exploratory to understand what actives works better for me before i venture to try other products/DIY.I have bought a batch from DECIEM including Hylamide (SubQ is more powerful than Buffet) and NIODalso have bought from Skin Activeswill be in DIY heaven… and skin care exploratory mode.So far round 1. Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate wins Anhdryous LAA!November 28, 2016 at 2:18 am #96712preciousiaMemberYes 25% vitamin E is too much.. i was told they have 25% vitamin C!i have emailed the company Moogoo for clarification.Update: they repliedHi Eunice,
Thank you for your email, it’s lovely to hear from you! J
Our Super Vitamin C Serum contains 25% Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate. (“Super” Vitamin C). 25% Natural Vitamin E and 50% Olive Squalane.
Unfortunately we don’t offer samples of the serums sorry. I hope this helps! If you have any other questions or require any more information, please don’t hesitate to get in contact again! J
Many Moos,
Shan
@Peter why is 25% Vitamin E bad?
November 28, 2016 at 2:22 am #96713preciousiaMember@Peter i have a book which talked more about glycol. i will share that with you. :)perhaps take a photo of the relevant pages.
i think i have your email (freenet.de)? is that yours?November 28, 2016 at 2:25 am #96714preciousiaMemberRe: The Ordinary packagingNo doubt. airless is better. they can justify all they want.>With such low viscosities, airless pumps are not the ideal choice as the pressure causes a harsh spurt to come out and splash in your hand.rubbish, you can buy airless bottle that are suitable for low viscosity>You can use Niacinamide with any other product, such as the Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate, Ascorbyl Glucoside, Matrixyl and Magnesium Ascorbyl Phosphate. Niacinamide is completely safe to use with C25 from Hylamide and Ethylated L-Ascorbic Acid 30% Network from NIOD.Thanks for sharing this. exactly what i need to know!November 28, 2016 at 2:26 am #96715preciousiaMemberi went berserk and bought this during their black friday sales >60% off- HYLAMIDE
- Technologically advanced daily treatments with SubQ multi-depth delivery mechanism.
- Bought:
- Hylamide Subq Anti-Age – 30ml RRP$57
- A highly active concentrate of advanced hyaluronic complexes, next-generation peptides and biotechnological technologies to target rehydration, while improving the look of lines, wrinkles, sagging skin and textural damage.
- Hylamide Subq Eyes – 15ml RRP$52
- High-strength serum concentrate uses a wide array of peptides, plant saccharides and active technologies to rehydrate the fragile eye area, while targeted technologies improve the look of fine lines, crow’s feet, puffiness and dark circles.
- Hylamide High Efficiency Face Cleaner – 120ml RRP$29.95
- Balancing face cleaner and makeup remover
- Hylamide Hydra-Density Mist – 120ml RRP$27
- Advanced treatment to support dermal water density for intense lightweight hydration and comfort.
- NIOD
- NIOD is a professional range to complement dermatological and surgical options in beauty.
- Bought
- NIOD Copper Amino Isolate Serum 1% RRP$90
- with Copper Tripeptide GHK-Cu helps to prevent and reverse largely all aspects of visible skin ageing.
- NIOD Superoxide Dismutase Saccharide Mist RRP$75
- a dermal treatment face and body mist to hydrate & protect skin against dehydration and oxidative damage.
- NIOD Sanskrit Saponins 90ml RRP$34
- an intense face cleaning balm unlike many cleansing face balms. Contains natural saponins derived from Ayurvedic plants which respect the skin’s integrity whilst deep cleansing skin.
- NIOD Mastic Must RRP$56
- Mastic Must is a pore cleansing masque with mastic gum derived from Greek Mastic trees to purify and shrink open pores.
- NIOD Voicemail Masque RRP$70
- a night time masque to target visible dullness and compromised skin tone as a result of stress and/or environmental conditions.
- NIOD Multi-Molecular Hyaluronic Complex RRP$50
- combines 12 forms of hyaluronic compounds to visibly hydrate skin.
- NIOD Photography Fluid, Opacity 12% – 30ml RRP$45
- A novel approach to creating a foundation for skin that reflects even radiance in life and very specifically through the camera lens, this instant treatment is serum-textured but contains a wide array of light refracting prisms, tone and hue correctors and topical photo-finishing technologies to offer even radiance within seconds.
- NIOD Flavanone Mud – 50ml RRP$59
- Flavanone Mud is a three-phase rinse-off decongestion system that disrupts neither the skin surface equilibrium nor its density. While FM can be classified as a masque for categorical convenience, its approach varies substantially from that offered by the concept of masques today both in terms of its way of positive visible influence on the skin as well as its respect for dermal integrity.
November 28, 2016 at 7:53 pm #96723PeterMemberOne product with all actives would be nice, on the other hand with many products that do combine multiple actives you don’t know anything about the percentages. Like the products from Paula’s Choice, her antioxidants serums and many of her moisturizers contain very good actives, but at what percentage? Also the claimed higher strength products from Paula’s Choice are quite expensive. If you consider the antioxidant serums contain 0.01% to 0.03% retinol, it looks like the products are probably >90% silicones. The Paula’s Choice 1% retinol costs 56 dollars, compared to a 2% retinoid at 9.80 from The Ordinary. With the Ordinary you are sure, that the one active they do use, is added at a percentage that’s proven to work the seperate products aren’t expensive and are not chock-full . But using 6 different serums to get all your actives, will dilute the final concentration as well. The only thing, hopefully the products are indeed stable and don’t oxidize in the dropper packaging, they claim the final product is completely stable. If they really are stable, and remain potent The Ordinary has some nice products I think.So my final verdict on my favorite brands up till nowThe Ordinary (from canada)+ cheap+ very high concentrations of proven actives+ easy to choose the actives/products that you would like+ almost no irritants+ no fragrance– you need to combine multiple serums to get all actives which dilutes products, and makes your routine quite expensive in the end anyway– they don’t offer all ingredients I would like to havePaula’s Choice (from usa)+ only proven plant actives, no phototoxic irritant plant extracts+ very good exfoliants+ multiple actives per product/serum+ almost every active you would like to have can be found in one of her products– low concentrations probably! If I don’t know what percentage is used, I can’t decide if the product will work.– high strength products are expensive, and you don’t know the percentage of the other ingredients in the product– too many options. I mean even if I would like to choose a product, I can’t decide. It feels like there are like 100 different options to choose from, why isn’t it possible to formulate 2 products per category (dry skin/ oily skin). Literally this is the reason I never have bought any full-size products, because I can’t decide what I need to have based on the samples.Uncover Skincare (from The Netherlands)+ high strength proven actives+ no fragrance or any irritants+ airless pump bottles (moisturizer at distribution center is stored in refrigerator to keep actives stable!)+ very easy to choose products (only two lines)– very expensive– limited range of active ingredients– SPF30 sunscreen leaves a white cast (unfortunately it’s the best sunscreen I’ve ever seen based on the ingredients)Derma Sun (from Denmark)+ Best and safest sunscreen actives+ Very cheap+ No irritants or fragrances, very simple formula, no white cast+ Face products packaged in airless pump bottles– no antioxidants or other active ingredients– although the product for the face claims to have a matte finish, I find it quite shiny.Considering sunscreens by now I’ve tried something like 30-40 different sunscreens, but really the miracle sunscreen I haven’t found. Of course I only want a fragrance free sunscreen, with stable safe sunscreen actives, so that limits my choice.November 30, 2016 at 1:02 pm #96727pazzagliaMemberWell, I couldn’t resist the curiosity – so I finally dove in and bought three The Ordinary Products:
– Vitamin C suspession (in the tube)– The Buffet– Caffiene Eye SerumI was so excited I slathered on “The Buffet” last night after my Italian Retin-A .05% equivalent. I told my self I should wait a couple of days before trying the Vitamin C – but this morning I was so excited I slathered that on right after washing my face. Big mistake. OMG – I think I burned my face off! It was so red and tingly. It is DEFINITELY a higher concentration than the Timeless or anything that I was using before.Things I learned: only try one product at a time – EVEN if I’m so excited I want to put on everything and… dilute this Vitamin C.Now I’m wishing I’d gotten the Niacin amide serum, too, to calm everything down! Because, you KNOW I would have tried that too – on the SAME DAY!!HAhahah!Other than the excitement, I somewhat know what I’m doing and I’ve used these kinds of ingredients before. I have no idea what someone who doesn’t know what they’re doing is going to do to their face with such easy and cheap access to such powerful ingredients.Ciao,LP.S. I got free shipping from the DECIEM website – to Italy!P.P.S. I must buy MORE!!November 30, 2016 at 9:37 pm #96729preciousiaMember@Peter some actives, do not require high concentration. I shall go thru your wish list and check the recommended % and solubility And see if it is possible to create them in 1 or 2 products.
Good review of the Brands
November 30, 2016 at 9:38 pm #96730preciousiaMember@Pazzaglia whoa! Patch test!!!
Love to hear more of your reviews! Once you have used it for much longer.
-
AuthorPosts
- The forum ‘Ask the Beauty Brains’ is closed to new topics and replies.