Lydia’s lost… Ok, I know that I spend way too much time shopping online when I have this fact stuck in my head: Bag Balm is the #3 best selling beauty product on Amazon.com. What’s up with that?!? What’s in this stuff, what does it do, and do I need to buy some?
The Left Brain’s leading reply:
Bag Balm reminds me of “Mane ‘n Tail:” They are both products designed for animals that humans have adopted for their own use. That’s right, Bag Balm is actually a product intended to treat skin condition of animals.
Bombastic about Bag Balm
According to the website for Dairy Association Company, Inc, the company that makes Bag Balm, it’s been used since 1899 to keep cows from becoming chapped. I assume this means it’s used to moisturize and protect the sensitive skin of the udders. For more background on the history of Bag Balm read this USA Today article. Just for the record, the website makes no mention of use on humans, which is not surprising since the product contains a drug active that is not approved for over the counter use on people.
Bag Balm ingredients
Since this isn’t a typical cosmetic product it doesn’t have to follow the labeling rules for cosmetics and therefore the package doesn’t have to carry a complete list of ingredients. But according to Drugstore.com I see that it contains 8-Hydroxyquinoline Sulfate at 0.3% in a petrolatum and lanolin base. Petrolatum and lanolin are both common skin care ingredients and are also used in heavy duty ointments and wound care products. The real star of the show is the 8-Hydroxyquinoline Sulfate. According to several sources such as this one, this compound is a bacteriostatic and fungistatic agent and it’s used to prepare antiseptics, deodorants, antiperspirants, and fungicides. (Personally, I’ve never seen this used in any products for humans.)
The Beauty Brains bottom line
I see Bag Balm as a product that combines excellent moisturizing ingredients with a drug active that has antiseptic properties. However, since the active agent is not approved for use on people, the company can not legally make claims in this regard. You may see benefits from using it but legally the company can only promote it for use on animals.
What do YOU think? Have you ever used Bag Balm or Mane ‘n Tail? Leave a comment and share your animalistic thoughts with the rest of the Beauty Brains community.
{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }
I never found Bag Balm all that great for moisturizing. However, I have used it when I needed to make a poultice. Like when I stepped on some broken glass and a piece was way too deep in my heel to get it out without going to the hospital. What I did instead is take some Bag Balm and some Tiger Balm, mix them together with some Neosporin and epsom salts, put it on along with a huge bandage, then a sock on top of that. Next morning the glass was right there at the surface of the skin and I just had to scrap my nail along it to get it out.
I can’t seem to find Tiger Balm anymore but I still use the Bag Balm/Neosporin/epsom salt combo whenever I need a poultice for a deep and/or nastily infected wound.
Bag Balm seems to be one of those ‘cult items’ that take on mythological status. Creamy Vaseline is my favourite. It works incredibly well for me–and it smells far, far better than the Bag Balm.
Jami–if you have any Asian grocery stores around, try them. That’s where I get my Tiger Balm. The prices are usually better and they often carry white Tiger Balm which I like a little better. Once, I even found Tiger Balm patches which are a dream with migraines.
My grandparents used to keep cows, and my Dad helped with the farm and showed them at fairs. They kept Bag Balm for the milkers whose teats, as you can imagine, sometimes become irritated or dry.
Fast forward about 20 years, and I still have a jar in my room. I use it for rough feet; my Dad’s used it for years for cracks on his hands.
It’s certainly not a miracle in a jar, but it works well for really dry, rough skin.
Remember the father in My Big Fat Greek Wedding and his “thing” with Windex? Yeah, that’s how I am with the Bag Balm! LOL
Got a cut, scrape, chapped lips, or cracked skin on your hands? Put some Bag Balm on it. It definitely helps skin heal faster and with less or no scarring. I’m not saying it’s the best thing out there for everything (I prefer Heel Balm for my feet and the flaky skin on my knuckles in winter. It sloughs off dead skin really well.) but it is really good at helping skin heal.
The funny thing is that it may not be approved for human use, but you pretty much have to get it on your hands to apply it to the cows.
Jami, Tiger Balm is available at Whole Foods. And I agree, Bag Balm is like Eucerin – much too greasy for moisturizing, but great for other purposes. I have used it for the antisepitic/antifungal properties on my cats.
I’ve never seen this before but it does sounds rather interesting. MOOOve over daisy, I need moisturising (although I must say, it does sound a bit heavy for daily use)
I used to live on a farm and the tendency is to use what you have on hand. Farmers can’t afford to waste their money on stuff that doesn’t work on their animals. These products usually come in large amounts and reasonably priced, and if something works on the animals, it’s a fair bet that it works on people too. These days, I don’t have farm animals so I don’t have these products around anymore, but if I did, I’d probably use them again.
I might have a few second thoughts about the medications in them though, now that you’ve pointed out they’re not approved for humans. We have a much longer lifespan in which be affected by such things than the average farm animal.
Should you use bag balm for everyday use? Probably not, but when you get sunburned lips or chapped lips beyond average proportions, grab the bag balm. Drool in your sleep and get small cuts at the corner of your mouth? Bag Balm…Petrolatum and Lanolin are great emollients that seal moisture in and the anti-septic is both anti-bacterial and anti-fungal, which are the two main causes of angular cheilitis.
This stuff does work, and considering most people probably use it a few times a year, I’m not too worried about the long term effects.
For those that would like the translation to the safety codes on the MSDS for 8-hydroxyquinoline sulfate, XN means may cause damage to health, R22 means harmful if swallowed, and S36 means wear suitable protective clothing. See http://www.hse.gov.uk/chip/phrases.htm
Keep in mind that those are for full strength 8-hydroxyquinoline sulfate, and not for the small .3% suspension in Bag Balm.
My grandparents introduced the green tin to me when I was little and I love the stuff. My local drugstore sells it. I use it for pimples, dry skin, windburned skin, cuts, scrapes, chapped lips, a surgical incision, sore skin from diarrhea, irritated skin from shaving, diaper rash, and probably more that I can’t remember. Basically the uses for this stuff is endless.
I have a small container next to where I sit and a large container in the bathroom. If it was avaible in tubes I would carry some in my purse.
I have a horribly weird, bumpy, itchy, dry patch on one ankle where the skin is thick and discolored. I have been to five doctors about it, including two different dermatologists, and nothing they have given me helps. I have tried all sorts of over the counter stuff too. Bag balm has done the most good so far. I put it on at night, wear some socks to bed, and in the morning the skin is almost normal again.
I always have Bag Balm on hand. I use it on my cats, dogs & myself. Gets rid of rashes, heals wounds & a really wonderful thing is if you use it everyday & work it into the skin using a plastic masager it gets rid of stretchmarks !!! It helps with sunburns & for someone with very sensitive, fair skin thats important. I also rub it into my nails, helps them grow strong, stops peeling & helps prevent hangnails. I have been experimenting with using a dab of it on the corners of my eyes. The moisture should help keep crows feet at bay. I have noticed a slight improvement.
{ 4 trackbacks }