Are you curious about natural mineral makeup?
The Beauty Brains are researching mineral based makeup products for an upcoming project and we want to make sure we look at the brands that YOU are interested in. If you have questions about specific mineral makeup brands, let us know and we’ll be sure to include them in our analysis.
Just leave a comment with the brand name and we’ll look into it for you. And stay tuned to the Beauty Brains next month for more details!
–Mid Brain
Tell us the brands of mineral makeup you’re interested in!
interestedbeauty Says:
i am interested in the use of bismuth in mineral make up. I have been told that this is a cheap filler in mineral make up, and that is why after using make up for a while, you can become itchy.
Lilia Says:
I’ve been buying Silk Naturals available online and would like to learn more about it. Thanks.
viannee Says:
I tried signature minerals and my skin liked it. I’ve been hearing a lot of raves about monave, silk naturals and joppa. i hope you can add it. thanks.
Anna Says:
I use Bare Minerals eyeshadows, Physician’s formula and L’oreal mineral face powders.
Pam Says:
I used Jane Iredale Pure pressed Base almost daily for about three years. I have rosacea, seb dermatitis, and overall sensitive skin. It never was irritating. I am satisfied with the coverage of my redness, and the color, Warm Silk, is very natural and a great match. It is very expensive, and since in the last year my skin has improved I have started using a liquid makeup that is more affordable, and has better coverage. I can tell you three things about the Jane Iredale that you might find useful. I live in Florida, and the saleswoman tod me to get the pressed base, not the loose mineral foundation, because in our humidity the loose one might get caked up. I never tried a loose version, so I don’t know if that would have happened. Another thing: I have always had blackheads, and while using this makeup I tried to get rid of them using BHA exfoliant, with no success. I wonder if this was because the titanium dioxide in this makeup worsened the clogging of my pores. Lastly, a few times I dropped the compact and the powder broke apart. (Not every time I dropped it, though.)
Lynn Says:
I love bare minerals. All the products are great.
Sue Says:
I’ve used Physician’s Formula (it was on sale :-)). I don’t know WHY it covers well or WHY it lasts longer than my liquid foundation but I’d like to learn. I’d also love to know more about other brands people like.
Candice Says:
Bare Escentuals
Diana Says:
I’ve tried Bare Escentuals, Jane Irendale and Meow Cosmetics in the past. I think I like Jane Irendale the best but it is also the most expensive.
GothicRapunzel Says:
I’m curious about everyday minerals, and I’m curious to see how the different mineral makeup companies stack up against each other.
Elaine Says:
I’m very interested in what you find regarding mineral makeups, in fact what defines it as “mineral” vs. other powder foundations. I have been using Clinique’s Superpowder Double Face Makeup for years and love it. The mineral makeup marketers love to say how bad the talc in other powders is, but talc is a mineral too!
spartan Says:
i am currently experimenting with meow and youngblood. i’m hoping you can help answer what mineral foundation is best for over-50 skin and roseacea.
Clara Says:
I luv Valana Minerals. Great selection of colors that doesn’t make me look pale or chalky.
Isabel Says:
I just saw that Avon now has a line of mineral makeup. I use Bare Escentuals but am wondering how’s the Avon line since it’s more affordable.
Anna Says:
I want to mention something interestng I was told about Bare essentials eyeshadow by a Sephora sales rep. She told me that there was no expiration date for the eyeshadows, since “it was impossible for them to go bad” she told me they they could be used indefinitely.
I don’t know, sounds a little hokey to me!
girl150 Says:
I’d like to learn more about L’Oreal and Mary Kay mineral make-ups.
dancerjodi Says:
I’ve been using http://www.everydayminerals.com/
anonymiss Says:
Another Everyday Minerals user here. Would love to hear your thoughts on this very affordable mineral makeup. I definitely prefer it to some of the more expensive brands (and not only because of the price). Bare Escentuals, for example, feels gritty compared to Everyday Minerals, IMO.
Ani Says:
I’d like to hear about the drugstore brands, Physician’s Formula particularly.
koko Says:
I was recently diagnosed with rosacea and seborrheic dermatitis, and my dermatologist instructed me to stick with noncomedogenic products. I had been using Bare Escentuals (Bare Minerals) and though I’m not sure it was exacerbating my conditions, I did notice that it made my skin itchy. I had heard anecdotally that BE was noncomedogenic, but could not find this claim on any of their packaging. So I began hunting for a new mineral makeup. The only ones I could find that are labeled as noncomedogenic are Jane Iredale and Youngblood. I’ve swtiched over to Jane Iredale as a result, and I’ve noticed that my skin is not itching. I’d like to know what it is about some mineral makeups that causes itching (I’ve read that it has to do with bismuth and/or parabens). And I’d also like to know whether mineral makeup is in fact “good for your skin,” which is what so many purveyors of this stuff claim. Lastly, I’d like to know whether the amount of natural sunscreen in these products–titanium dioxide, etc.–is sufficient to obviate the need for a separate sunscreen product, and whether it provides broad spectrum protection.
Marnie Says:
I have been using Bare Escentuals for a while and I liked the look, but felt that after a few hours it looked somewhat caked (but I might be using too much). I esp like their concealer and brush. I just bought Jane Iredale loose powder foundation because I had heard rave reviews, but I find that the coverage isn’t as good. Neither product seemed to “help” my skin as they claim (same blackheads, same acne bumps, same blotchiness). They both do look fantastic on camera.
Sage Says:
I am very curious about the Bare Escentuals product called RareMinerals Skin Revival Treatment. I honestly think it’s a total crock but the way they are marketing it is genius. I tried it and found it to do pretty much nothing. And you should see the literature that comes with this stuff — such a load of utter fiction (”we use ancient soil” blah blah blah). But I’d love to read what you uncover about this. Thanks.
Carol Ann Says:
I love Bare Escentuals Bisque. I use it for concealer and for foundation. It’s the only thing that makes my skin look flawless and stays on. I am 51, with dry skin and rosacea. It covers the rosacea and the dark pigmentation around one of my eyes.
Lillybeth Says:
Mary Kay’s mineral foundation (been in the states for ages but being launch in New Zealand in May…) and Avon’s too. Please!!?! Comparisons would be AWESOME. Thanks so much.
xx
Lillybeth
Lisa Says:
I use Philosophy’s supernatural. I have notice increased breakouts in the last year I wonder if it is due to the mineral makeup. I have been using it for 3 years first bare minerals now philosophy because of the application sponge. I do not think the makeup is better for me but i do like that i do not feel it on my face. I am considering trying Laura Geller’s baked foundation as an alternative. if you have any knowledge about this line it would be very helpful.Thanks.
lina Says:
Everyday Minerals
Mary-K Says:
Mary Kay Cosmetics has recently launched a great mineral powder foundation as well as mineral powder color products. I love how my skin looks like it is naturally flawless rather than just “covered up” with other foundations.
Mindy Says:
J. Lynne Cosmetics has some nice trial sizes. http://www.jlynnecosmetics.com/ I still haven’t found a good color match, however.
Cara Says:
Another vote for Everyday Minerals. I personally used the foundation, concealer and finishing dust.
I also wanted to say that I just discovered this site the other day and I am loving it. It appeals to both my girly and geeky sides.
Miss Laura Mars Says:
Physician’s Formula vote!
Cassie Says:
I love everydayminerals.com as well. It’s so affordable and it has been a wonderful product to use. I also like their shadows and blushes.
Marie Says:
I’ve used Bare Escentuals which I found to cover very well. Currently I’m using Silk Naturals & The Natural Source but I don’t find that they cover as well as BE.
Christi Says:
Almay has a new mineral foundation — Pure Blends — and I’d like to know how much these powders are or aren’t appropriate for sensitive skin since that is a focus in the brand’s reputation.
And this segues into my next question which is: Could you give a rundown on ingredients that are commonly used and what their purposes are?
Thanks so much.
Busylizzie Says:
Hi! I’ve only used Physician’s Formula so far, and would love to hear how it stacks up. Thanks.
Izumi Says:
I’ve been curious about Dr.Hauschka makeup. The SA told me that it’s been a mineral-based makeup line long before all the hype surrounding mineral makeup.
Pam Says:
Meow Cosmetics, Alima, and Pure Luxe are smaller brands that a lot of people seem to like. I’d love to know how they rank against the big guns!
Betty Says:
I use Neutrogena mineral make-up. Please let us know if mineral make-up is better for mature, dry skin prone to whiteheads, than liquid foundation. Thanks
Lynnette Says:
Jane Iredale and Glo Minerals, please.
–PAM– if you drop the compact, the powder will break apart. NO need to toss it though, as you can just make it inot a powder. That will not constitute it being a loose. Any product that is dropped in the compact should break.
buenos dias,
Lynnette
Joanie Says:
Audrey Morris
Aruna Says:
I like urban decay’s hallucination shade. love it actually, heavy coverage or light depending on what you want. more yellow base than most pinky ones and best of all… no glitter.
Lucia Says:
Bare escentuals, it makes my skin look fabulous
Monica Says:
I have tried Bare Minerals, Glo, Jane Iredale and Arbonne. Bare Minerals caused itching. By far my favorite was Jane Iredale but the price was a bit steep. I was told by a Jane Iredale rep to apply the minerals in downward strokes to create a more “matte” vs glowing look. She explained that the minerals are tiny flakes, and when aplied in downward strokes it creates application perfection. The individual mineral “flakes” lie like fish scales, overlapping slightly, which creates a smooth finish. I noticed everywhere else they suggest application with a swirling motion of brush. Would love to hear your thoughts on application…I currently use Arbonne and have been very happy with their mineral makeup line and cost.
Catarina Says:
I am curious about Laura Mercier and Bare Escentuals. Thanks!
Cathy Says:
SheerCover
Misty Says:
Bare Escentuals, Philosophy Supernatural, Neutrogena Pressed Minerals, Garden Botanika (brand new), Almay, Pur Minerals
Jessica Says:
I love Pure Luxe Cosmetics. You can buy 1.00 samples that come in little containers, not the messy plastic bags.
Alcy Says:
Jane Iredale because they have a pressed foundation.
gaflower Says:
Jane Iredale gets my vote! I am an aesthetician student and we use it at our school…great coverage…perfect color matching and the product lasts quite a long time. I personally would pay a little more for the perfect color and coverage….correct on using downward strokes in application also using a flat bronzer type brush! You can also purchase sample sizes online to try before you buy!
Donna frederick-Neznek Says:
I started out using Bare Minerals.
I was very pleased with them until one day @ the Spa, when I tried the True line of minerals. I found them to be more “natural” looking and comparative in price. This was only the second mineral i have tried, but i have seen a big difference in opacity between True & Bare Minerals. I still use a cream concealer prior to application as I have found neither really gives me the coverage I desire. Is there something out there that gives the coverage (sans concealer) without the look of build-up?
EMiriamD Says:
In addition to the usual suspects I’m interested in Kathleen Minerals Cover-Silk mineral foundation, which comes in both powder and liquid form. The Makeup Artists Choice website, which is where I first saw this line, says it does not contain bismuth. Curious to see what the Beauty Brains have to say about it!
Allie Says:
Bare Minerals. Good coverage. Doesn’t melt off in the heat.
Maybelline Mineral Power Natural Perfecting Foundation–It is a liquid. What in the world is this? How is it different than other liquid foundations?
Kari Says:
I’m interested in Maybelline Mineral Powder Natural Perfecting Foundation. I’ve been using it now for only about a week, so I can’t say whether or not it’s doing any good for my skin.
Meresankh Says:
I use Bare Escentuals Bare Minerals, and have for a few years now. I have no complaints, but I wouldn’t mind knowing how other mineral make-ups stack up.
MR Says:
Could you research different brands? I’m curious about mineral makeup, but I’m not up to spending $60 on Bare Escentuals. Could you compare that and other pricey brands with the mineral lines from Avon, Physicians Formula, Maybelline, and other drugstore brands? I want to see whether the cheaper ones work as well as the pricey ones.
makeupmonkey Says:
I’d like to see more information on Bare Escentuals and Everyday Minerals.
Debbie Says:
I use glominerals, I have for a couple of years now. I also recently ordered the e.l.f. mineral concealer to try. I am getting used to it. I will be very interested in the results of this research. Thank you!
Julia Says:
I have been using Bare Escentuals Minerals AD for about a year. I am 54 yrs old and had a hard time finding a makeup that worked with my changing complexion and coloring. I love this product. I am complemented on my complexion - and I have never had those compliments. I believe that this makeup evens out the tones of my skin, provides a special glow to my complexion. I even forget to take it off at night and don’t have the tell-tale clogs in the morning. Neither do I have that dryed caked feeling that I get with other makeups.
But mostly, I just like that it evens my skin tones and makes me look younger. Call me a fool -and not a beauty brains girl - but I do believe it works!
BTW it also works for my 60 yr old sister in law. She has recommended it to so many happy campers that she thinks she should get a commission!
J. Rose Says:
I have been using Erth Minerals for about a year now. I love the products & love the fact that they don’t use nanoparticles or bismuth like some other brands. They also have nice trial-size kits & they are way more affordable than some of the other brands I’ve tried.
http://www.lushbrush.com
cindy martina Says:
I am a consultant for Seriesse International, and we just released a line of mineral based foundations, blushes etc. They are incredible & priced affordably.
cindy martina Says:
PS: regarding Seriesse International,
please visit my website for product & business opportunity information.
http://www.myseriesse.com/logansmom
or consultant # 119035
Kaumealani Says:
I use Artistry, http://www.quixtar.com
cindy Says:
kaumealani, you might want to consider Seriesse ( see comment before yours)… it will be a fraction of the cost.
Ale Says:
There are so many brands it is hard to figure out where to start with! If I were to mention brands I’m interested in: Everyday Minerals, Silk Naturals
However, I think it would be even more useful to go over the main ingredients and claims. Like the sun protection due to the use of titanium and zinc oxides. I’ve also heard that mineral powders can’t harbor bacteria and thus are safe to use for years. For makeup containing foody ingredients (eg. rice powder, cornstarch), I’ve heard that they can sustain bacteria more easily and thus can go bad, but also that they can feed the bacteria that causes acne. And there are the terms comedogenic and micronized ingredients.
I must say that the reasons I’m attracted to mineral makeup are that the list of ingredients is short and usually free of irritating fragrance, and the dazzling variety of shades. If I can think of any other claims that have made me raise an eyebrow, I’ll post back.
Liz Says:
I use EveryDay Minerals. They seem to have less ingredients than other brands, and I am curious if this makes them “better.”
Kerry Says:
I used Bare Minerals for 8 years and it ended up destroying my skin with cystic acne and scarring. I am currently using Everyday Minerals, and I am curious to see the results of your research!
lina flick Says:
i am curious about pure luxe cosmetics, aromaleigh (they seem to have the most exciting colors online) everyday minerals (i used a sample of their semi-matte foundation and it was quite nice). i’m also curious if the antioxidants in mineral essence brand and julie hewett’s mineral makeup are really beneficial or if they’re too low in concentration to do anything - thanks!
Liz Says:
I’ve used the Colorescience mineral makeup for several years. I’ve had good results and a good color match. I’m curious to know if the SPF claims are valid and if the makeup is good for the skin, as the company claims in its marketing. The makeup is very expensive and I’d also like to know if it’s any better than the mineral makeup available in drug stores. –Thanks!
Laura Says:
My favorite is illuminare liquid mineral make-up. It doesn’t look dry like the powders and it’s not messy to use either. it lasts all day and has an spf21. it’s also really gentle on my sensative skin.
Kerry Says:
Curious about Physicians Formula Mineral Wear pressed powder, and how it compares to higher end loose mmu.
judith Says:
i generally use bare escentuals along with tarte mineral powder, however i recently got some mineral makeup for a costume from rickys - its called matisse nyc. im a little curious about that one, and whether or not its safe to use.
i would also like to know about laura mercier’s line of mineral powders…and ive also been wondering what the difference between bare escentuals and guthy renker’s sheer cover is!
Sheila Says:
Colorescience is definitely the best. Look into their beware compare test. Their Sunforgettable SPF 30 and Suncanny Foundation are both rated as an over-the-counter drug by the FDA, which tells you that in addition to the excellent wear, the sun protection is in fact stable and highly water resistant. Simply the best out there.
Anabeana Says:
Physicians Formula. It was on sale. It lasts longer and I don’t break out as much any more.
Autumn Says:
L’oreal just launched a line of mineral foundation/finishing powder/blush and eyeshadow. I’d like to see this reviewed as well. I like it so far, but am curious as to how it stands up to other brands.
Kimberly Says:
Love Bare Escuentuals from Sephora.
I have a corn allergy, so I have to be wary of makeup fillers.
J Says:
mineralmakeupmania.com is a fantastic resource, especially for foundation ingredients.
Linda Says:
Hi. I have used liquid and powder mineral makeup from Jane Iredale, Lavera, Terra Firma and Aromaleigh. Lavera is by far my favorite, but the coverage is very, very sheer. I usually end up combining it with another product.
I was also curious if you would look at Franche`. It is a line made in Houston. Their claim to fame is freeze dried minerals, but I would love to hear about it before a spend another $75.00 on one product.
Thank you.
Aileen Says:
I am very interested in Mineral foundations and would like to learn which would be the best brand to try. I am acne prone and have sensitive skin. I have read about Bare Minerals, Bare Escuentuals from Sephora, as well as Revlon ColorStay Mineral Foundation. I would really appreciate an opinion on these and any other Mineral type makeup for my type of skin.
Thanks!!
boo Says:
I would be interested in hearing your thoughts about Meow Cosmetics and Everyday Minerals
Cate Says:
Holy Moly! I was just looking through the comments section over the weekend and there were like 6…now 78!! 79 even! Wow!
I use Bare Escentuals right now and have been using it for years…love love LOVE it!…..but part of me wants to try Jane Iredale. I have heard a lot of positive comments about it and there is a retailer in town apparently. Even better!
Allison Says:
how bout Everyday Minerals
Lenore Dorfman Says:
I love Bare escentuals but wonder if the new less expensive drugstore brands are just as pure-such as Neutrogena and Loreal
Quin Says:
I have dark brown skin and the only brand that looks great on me and doesn’t make me break out is Valana Minerals. Most companies don’t have colors for people like me with dark brown skin so I’m happy with Valana.
Jenna Says:
hey i also am a huge raver of BE however i am extremely curious as to whether the ingredients in youngblood or Jane Iredale are better?? also from reading another post i am also extremely curious about Dr.Hauschka’s line of mineral makeup if it is in fact created by a real Dr. and is therefore perhaps better for your skin??
VERY CURIOUS. CANT WAIT FOR RESULTS!
Judy Says:
I just read an article about mineral makeup and one products spokesperson actually said she would put on her makeup at night and sleep in it if she had to be our early the next day. Is she for real?
Judy Says:
Sorry, I meant if she had to be OUT (not our) early the next day.
laura Says:
I use and like everyday minerals… http://www.everydayminerals.com/
Lil Says:
I love Suncat mineral make up, it’s the best I’ve used so far closely followed by Everyday minerals. I do hope Suncat is covered and I can’t believe it’s not been mentioned yet.
Anna2 Says:
I began experimenting with mineral makeups some years ago when I began having rosacea-like symptoms. The minerals I tried at the time weren’t a good match at all, and they were too expensive, compared to other brands, but they DID seem to help my skin, so I kept wearing them til I used them up. Since then, I’ve sampled a LOT of brands, and my favorite for foundation is Alima, they’re the only brand I’ve found that makes a Cool shade that’s deep enough to actually match my skin tones. (I use a mix of C-3 and C-4)
Most brands try to get away with limiting their line to three or four shades in some weirdly warm/neutral tone that just makes me look dirty. Why do they do that?? Very frustrating.
Pure Luxe Cosmetics has some wonderful eye shadow shades, as does MAD Minerals.
I’m NOT a fan of Aromaleigh, no two containers of foundation that I bought were ever the same shade. I wore them for a good while, once I discovered them, since very few cosmetics companies seem to acknowledge my skintone as a shade. (Most seem to want me to cover my skin with some weirdly neutral tone to cancel out the ‘redness’ which only makes me look like a corpse.) I’ve also got issues with their notions of ‘customer service’.
britt Says:
I tried L’Oreal Bare Naturale powdered mineral foundation and was sorely disappointed. It was crumbly and the powder wouldn’t even stay on my face long enough to be applied. The brush was also poor quality. Once I used a better brush, the coverage was still blotchy.
Then for Valentine’s Day, my Husband got me Physician’s Formula Mineral Wear, which I like very much. I have the Face Powder, the Blush, and the Matte Finishing Veil. All three are great-fast and easy to use. The Finishing veil is designed most like L’Oreal’s, and it is a million times better. Plus, the Physician’s Formula will brush right off your clothes, but stay on your face all day.
anactoria Says:
I think I’ve used everything listed thusfar (BE, L’Oreal, Physicians Formula) and to be honest, the most expensive brand I used, La Bella Donna, was the best, save for the fact that it was far too dark for my skin! I have since tried Jane, Neutrogena (horrendous packaging), and Milani. I’d like to know the primary differences between the high and low end of mineral makesups since I have a hard time believing the formulations to be that different from each other.
Debbie Says:
I would like to know more about Avon’s mineral makeup Thanks.
skeptical hairdresser Says:
I had terrible reddish skin and used clinique and then lancombe liquid makeups. Then i switched to Bare Escentuals.
I don’t use it the way they say, I put on a thin thin touch of vaseline while my face is still wet, then I take the medium base and put it on my nose, around my nose, and chin, then I use any
kind of cheek stuff.Sometimes Bare Escentuals, sometimes something else.
Generally now my skin is 100% better!
MacRae Says:
I have used Jane Iredale. I have extremely sensitive, dry eyes and have a hard time wearing ANY eye makeup. The mineral shadows seem to work the best. Any advice about why this is? What do the minerals have or lack that make them less irritating than the traditional cosmetics? Please empower me to be a better label reader!
Jen Says:
Alima and Lumiere are my two favorite brands.
Laura Says:
Have only tried L’Oreal, and would like to know how it compares to the more expensive brands.
Teresa Says:
Aromaleigh
Keri Says:
I use Bare Escentuals myself but I am interested in learning more about the drugstore options like Loreal, Physician’s Formula, Maybelline, etc. and how they compare to BE. Can’t wait to see your review!
Cinnamon Says:
My sister bought all of us Bare Minerals starter kits for Christmas. I am 51 with fairly unlined skin for my age. While I like the color, the powder settles into wrinkles I didn’t even know I had after an hour or so. The more buffing, the drier my skin gets. Is this one of those products that works best for younger women?
Anja Says:
hello, i have lupus AND huge pores. i’m very light skinned but the lupus ’spots’ are much darker. i’ve had to stop using my liquid foundation because it just seemed to emfasize my pours, lines, and splotches MORE. Now i can’t figure out what company/maker of mineral make up i should try. HELP! i’d love to wear make up again!
~imp.
Angela B Says:
The best mineral makeup I have found is through Alima cosmetics based in Portland, Oregon. http://www.alimacosmetics.com
They are truly a Natural mineral makeup with no additives or harmful substances! I always get free samples and loyalty points! Wonderful makeup & company!!!
Anne Says:
Seems I’m the only one using Sheer Cover. I started with Bare Minerals and it didn’t work at all on my fare complexion. I looked orange!! My husband still talks about it. But, he and I both think I look great in Sheer Cover.
I am hard on makeup and expect to be able to put it on once and have it last all day. SC does. I don’t use much, however, because it will cake. And, I’m careful to avoid my eye area where, at 40, I have fine lines and the powder will settle and make me look old.
Bev Says:
I’m in my 50’s and have used a lot of makeup (think of the 60’s and the Twiggy look). I read in one of the magazines geared for my age that Neutrogena was good.
I tried it and like it and it covers the red pimples (from hormones or wine) very well.
Now I am real curious about the brands mentioned above.
Alison Says:
As a woman of color, I’ve had difficulty finding a mineral make up that didn’t leave a grayish tone. I’ve tried Bare Escentuals and recently tried Arbonne (which I love!).
Alic Says:
I’m currently using GloMinerals, which I love the feeling of - I wonder if the really high end brands are much better than, say the Physicians Formula. The GloMinerals promo material said that one of the reasons it and Jane Irydale were better brands was because they were more finely milled. Is that the only real difference?
constellar Says:
i am interested in an article that lets people know that many ‘mineral’ makeups are actually the same as mainstream, but with some added minerals ( such as most of those found in drugstores)
i am interested in makeup companies that do NOT use the cheap sunthetic filler of bismuth oxychloride.
i would like to see a complete review of jane iredale, mineral fusion which is found in whole foods, as well as the small but fine companies of monave, pure luxe, lumiere, fyrrinae , aromaleigh as well as any mineral makeup companies whose shades include pigments designed for women of color ( non ashy gray chalky)
i would like to kow if there are mineral makeup companies out there that offer formulas that are easy for travel ( small, compact rather than loose), strong pigments suitable for women of color and dramatic /theatrical use, and formulations that are extremely long lasting, as well as the aspect of more clean/pure and therefore more healthy.
thank you!
rosarita Says:
So many of the powdered mineral foundations become irritating to my skin over time. I’ve been using Neutrogena’s compact mineral foundation and so far so good - is there something in it that enables it to be in solid, compact form that makes it better for my skin than the powdered minerals? Do the minerals work differently if they are powdered as opposed to compressed?
rosarita Says:
I guess I should clarify that my question, above, refers to the new compact version of Neutrogena mineral foundation and not the old one that was distributed through a brush.
Memory Says:
I’m new to the make-up scene but bought a Bare Escentuals Bare Mineral starter kit. I enjoy it but haven’t tried anything else. I asked and was told by the sales woman that because it was all “minerals” that there was no expiration date, it wouldn’t go bad. But just a day ago as I was putting on my foundation I noticed on the side of the container “EXP 10/08″. Great! I had asked the question about expiration dates because I am not a heavy nor daily user of make up. If it has expired, what evil consequences will happen if I continue to use it?
I’m curious to learn from the Beauty Brains about any mineral company’s claim of “no expiration date”. Also the sunscreen SPF claims because perhaps I wear a lighter load of foundation than necessary to receive such SPF benefits. Additionally, in my starter kit I have the “i.d. bareVitamins skin rev-er upper”. I was told this product uses something that used to be prescription only, but they can use it in their product because (some doctor/oversight type person/agency) knows that BE wouldn’t put anything in their products that isn’t good for your skin. Sometimes I forget to put that on first, and wonder if my foundation, etc will still stay on. It does. So why use the other stuff? And what good does a ‘finishing powder’ (such as BE’s Mineral Veil) really do? I don’t always use it. In my mind it just could be more product to sell me.
I’m also curious about BE’s Platinum line. I think they also were advertising something about diamonds, but if I could afford diamonds, I’d rather wear them as jewelry rather than glitter spots on my face.
It’s great to read everyone’s comments and see the whole smorgazboard of mineral companies out there. I really look forward to your compilation on this topic Beauty Brains!
Dana Says:
I’m interested in Glo Minerals and Jane Iredale.
Does ANY mineral makeup work for rosacea, mid-stage (mostly red cheeks and chin)?
What minerals makeups work for sensitive skin, if any?
What are the components of an excellent mineral makeup?
Liz Says:
I’m a big fan of Mary Kay products, including their new line of mineral colors & foundations. In addtion to great quality, I also get great service from my consultant; she even calls me a few days after I buy something to make sure it’s working, and then offers to come get it from me & refund my money if I’m not completely happy. But, since I always get to try things before I buy them (with her teaching me how to use it properly), I rarely have to return anything!
Shannon Says:
I am curious about the RareMinerals Blemish Therapy; it is made by BareMinerals, and is a similar powder that you put on at night that claims to clear up blemishy skin… would it really work?
Jennfier Says:
Please review Colorescience mineral makeup- I am a professional makeup artist and have been using it for years. It’s the best!
Belle Says:
Please review Everyday Minerals. They are a lot cheaper then BE, and I want to know more about them. Thanks so much.
Grace Says:
I’m interested to know if Sheer Cover works as well as Bare Escentuals (and if Bare Escentuals works as well as the brand claims).
Melanie Says:
I have used mineral makeups for about 7 years now and in the last year have developed itchy skin with MU. I know blismuth is a problem in this regard, but what about micas. I have tried one mica free foundation from Beautyblisscosmetics.com and it looks very cakie on, but no itchiness. The best looking foundation I have found is Sterling Minerals, but again I have the itchiness even without the blismuth ingredient. I have recently found Rejuva Minerals at rejuvaminerals.com but I haven’t given them a try yet. They claim to be mica free, blismuth free, and titanium free. Please enlighten me in regards to all factors of itchiness and mineral makeups.
Rosa Says:
I’m interested in Everyday Minerals and BE Rare Minerals (night makeup???)
Nancy Says:
MAC Cosmetics. Their mineral makeup does contain talc, which some other brands don’t. I see “no talc” being used as a selling point. Why is this?
mamacita Says:
Interested in philosophy and Jane Iredale loose powder formulas.
Lana Says:
First time on this site! I Love It! I tried Bare Essentuals and liked the natural glow it gave me. I got a rash, and found out it had bismuth oxide. I later found that is nickel (which I am allergic to). I looked on the comments and see that seems to be a common issue with the minerals makeup. I am in search of a minerals product that does not contain bismuth oxide. I have a catalog for Arbonne and see they offer a minerals foundation, and I am wondering if it contains bismuth oxide?! I feel the makeup should list that it contains bismuth oxide since so many people are allergic to nickel (they even mark fake silver “nickel free”). Good Luck! Thanks!
Kim Says:
I use Lumiere and love it (what’s up with silk in mineral make-up, btw?)
But I am really curious about the claims several companies have been making about how wearing mineral makeup at night is beneficial for skin.
DM Says:
I want to know about Glo Minerals. I think they’re great! They have the same micronization as Jane Iredale but more colors that blend better so you don’t end up looking like an old lady……..
BUT.. they use mica. Is there anything wrong with mica?
Kate Says:
Mineral Fusions, please — this line has been a Whole Foods exclusive for a long time but they’re now starting to let smaller retailers sell it. I heard that the Whole Foods higher-ups loved GloMinerals but wanted something more environmentally sound, and so Mineral Fusions was born. I’d be very interested in a complete review of this line and others that claim to have high environmentally-based standards.
Hannah Says:
Bare Escentuals - i.d. bare minerals are my fav!
Kerri Says:
I am currently using Jane Iredale, mainly because they have pressed powder formulations. I’d love to see how it compares to other mineral makeup lines.
Patty Says:
I’ve just started using Jane Iredale’s Liquid Minerals. I’d like to know if it’s better than the Clinique non-oily liquid foundation I’ve used for years. I chose the liquid minerals formulation because loose powders seem to irritate my sinuses (I have allergies). Thanks much!
Schansen Says:
I am saddened that u are exploiting and toying to corrupt mineral make-up!!Mineral make-up is the future. If u are using mineral CORRECTLY it is ravishing.I use IDBare Escentuals. I don’t itch.I also use the Bare
Escen Night Treatment and it has tightened my pores! Also use PUR. U people then have an ad here for Ambien to promote sleep!! I nearly died on those drugs!!So say you about credibility. Leave mineral make-up alone.
Anja Says:
So when do we actually get the reviews for these products??? i’d LOVE to get some make up soon, but there’s just so many! Some say use this one, some say that one. i’ve read some have things in it that make the skin itch or break out. i’m so confussed. i have very fair skin, with dark tan and orange splotches from lupus; which also makes my skin VERY sensitive. i also have huge pours and not sure how to shrink them; and combination skin at that. Which mineral make up will cover all of these things without making them even more noticable (like liquid foundation and regular powder did; i might as well have used a red marker and circled all the areas instead!), yet blend well, and be ok with my skin problems???? Should i just see a dermatologist? Anyone else have any of these problems and could recommend something? i don’t have the money to just experament. HELP!!! This is all so confusing.
Come on Girls, surely we can figure SOMETHING out!!! i don’t care what it is as long as it works well and doesn’t hurt my skin. So glad there are many of you out there, like me saying “HUH???” when it comes to all this! LOL
XXOO* ~to all.
Kerri Says:
Oh yeah, I’d also love more info on NVEY ECO makeup. Thanks!
sammy-kay Says:
I love my Bella pierre mineral make up. The stack of colours i bought can be used dry as eyeshadow or blush, and when you dip your brush in water it turns into a beautiful shimmering eye liner or eyeshadow. when i bought it the stand was also adding the colours to a clear lip balm, lip gloss and nail polish, which made it look so versatile. I wasn’t too sure on what was acutally in the balm, gloss and polish so i didnt gte them, but the 10 colours i did get work great!!!
geraldine Says:
Hi in the uk on our shopping channel we have sheer cover .
It looks amazing but you pay £30 a month, this seems a lot of money to me. The cover seems to be down to the concealer, do all brands have this .Thanks -Geraldine
buffy Says:
I use glo minerals - not sure how it stacks up against the rest.
Nancy Says:
I’d love to hear how AVON’s mineral makeup compares to the others. I’ve used Bare Minerals but never could get it to look good, now matter what I did. I’d like to try another but don’t want’ to waste any more money than I have to!
Thanks,
Nancy
Kate P Says:
Hey Beauty Brainiacs! I was wondering if you guys could clarify a few things about mineral makeup for me:
-First off, they say that because MMU is all-natural, you can sleep in it and it won’t clog pores. When I heard that, my BS-o-meter went off - wouldn’t the oil on your face and the powder mix together and possibly clog pores?
-Second off, I use(d) Everyday Minerals for about 4 months and found that it made me seriously oily (WAY worse than normal) - are there ingredients in MMU that can make someone more oily? (for reference, I tried using different moisturizers, as well as no moisturizer and nothing made a difference)
-Lastly, I suspect that mineral makeup is making me break out really badly. What are some ingredients that could potentially be causing my breakouts (so I can try to avoid them in the future)?
You guys are awesome, and I’m hoping you can help decode mineral makeup for me!
Tobi Kramer Says:
interested in Mary Kay’s line of mineral makeup…but just interested in the mineral idea in general
Anne Says:
I’ve tried California Beauty Sudden Glow and Youngblood, but I just can’t get past the shimmer. I’d like a more matte texture. I’ve also noticed a slight itch as someone above mentioned.
J Says:
I am interested in uncoated minerals. Silicones make me break out. Most mineral products have coated zinc or titanium. Coated = silicone, and for me, that means breakouts.
Miroki Says:
I’ve been researching into Elegant Minerals recently but I have not seen ANY reviews on it save for those on the site. Their materials are very similar to all other all natural mineral products (no bismuth, etc.) It’s much cheaper than the name/tv/infomercial brands since it doesn’t spend money on promotions. They have AMAZING sample special offers so I think I may give them a try. I’m only hesitating cause of discovering Silk Naturals, and I’m wondering if the inclusion of silk may be better for my skin…of course I realize I can buy silk powder separately too…
Heather Says:
I currently use BE. I have been hearing good things about Avon minerla makeup. I have found a website http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com, they are part of the environmental working group. This website rates hazzardess igredients in products. I would like to know which mineral makeup is the best buy for pricing, coverage, correction or “healing”, and hazzard ratings. I would like a well rounded produst that is not tested on animals also. If there is such a product out there.
Marlena Burger Says:
I am 57 years old and I am considering using the Loreal product but are these Bare Minneral products just for the younger skin ? I would like to know from someone that has used it, in my age catagory.
Marlena
Cate Says:
How about The Secret Mineral Cosmetics. I was in the mall the other night and had them use their foundation on me. It looked nice except where she tried to cover some acne and then it looked caked. The following morning my face was so dry in that area. Apparently you can use the face colors for all your make-up needs–blush, eyeliner, shadow, mascara, even nail polish. They have a primer to make it waterproof. I tried looking them up online–but found nothing
The Fabulous Formula Says:
[...] head over to The Beauty Brains. They are researching mineral based products and are accepting questions about natural mineral makeup. If you are a woman of color (I am a dark-skinned [...]
Steph Says:
I’m interested in Everyday Minerals, it’s the only brand I’ve ever used and it’s fantastic as well as cheap, and that has me a bit confused. If it’s so great and doesn’t contain filler like they say, how can it be so affordable? I’m wondering if it’s not as pure as they say.
Also, I was curious which brands had Talc and if it was really as bad for you as I hear.
Marlena Burger Says:
OK…I see all the questions others have listed, where are the answers to these questions. Am I missing something?
TN Says:
I’ve been using Bare Escentuals Foundation with SPF 15. I like to know if this have enough sunblock for everyday. I like others to know if there is others brands that are just as good in coverage as this one since this is one of the pricier ones. I am thinking of buying the RareMinerals Blemish Therapy 2pc Kit since I do have adult acne.
Shaina Says:
I’ve used Aromaleigh for about six years and swear by it. My skin is extremely sensitive which is why I turned to mineral makeup in the first place, and I researched several companies before selecting Aromaleigh. I have incredibly sensitive, acne-prone skin, and this is the first line of makeup I’ve used (and I’m a beauty product junkie) that hasn’t created an allergic rash or acne breakout. The powders are talc- and bismuth oxychloride-free, and only “moist” products like some stick eyeliners and mascara contain chemicals like preservatives and fillers (a few of the moist products do contain talc, but they’re items that are used in small amounts like concealer and lash primer). Ingredients are stated clearly. My experience with color consistency has been different than a previous poster: I repurchase the foundation once per year and the color hasn’t fluctuated. The makeup stays put all day and in any weather - in fact, my makeup still looked fresh after a 14-hour excursion to Disneyland last week; also, I live on the coast where it’s humid year-round. Surprisingly, it also lasts through workouts. The makeup feels great on the skin, lightweight and never sticky or uncomfortable; because it doesn’t clog pores, it also lets skin “breathe.” Application is easy and quick and heavier or lighter coverage can be achieved simply by using different tools. The variety of colors is huge and continuously growing, and there are foundation shades for all skin tones and ethnicities. For those who are in between offered shades, extensive guidelines for mixing two or more shades to get the right color are given on the website. You can buy generous, inexpensive samples of every item before committing to purchasing full-size items (also a great way to try mixing colors if you need to). The full-sized items are huge, also inexpensive and last a long time. Finally, Aromaleigh has great customer service. Orders ship quickly and the prices are very reasonable, and coupons, sales, and free shipping are available. The creator of Aromaleigh cares about and listens to her customers, and some of the reformulations of products and new items and colors have been a direct response to customer’s requests. I apologize for the long post and sounding like a late-night infomercial, but I love this stuff so much that I wanted to give detailed information!
Shaina Says:
Just a quick Aromaleigh follow-up I didn’t mention above: customer reviews of each product are available and encouraged on the website. To J, both uncoated and coated formulations of the foundation powder are available. To Marlena, L’oreal doesn’t offer bona fide mineral makeup products - their products have added ingredients, like talc and aloe, whereas the “true” mineral makeup companies formulate their powders completely of minerals like titanium dioxide and finely milled mica. My 53-year-old mother uses mineral makeup (Aromaleigh and occasionally Bare Escentuals), and she loves it and looks fabulous!
Marlena Burger Says:
Thank you Shaina for this informative right-up and your extensive research on the subject. Marlena
lynn Says:
Revlon Color Stay Mineral Powder is the worst I have ever tried. Poor coverage and the little black bristles from the brush come off all over your face. Sure, it’s not expensive and I found out why!
Bernadette Says:
I am interested in Bare Minerals’ claim that it is water-resistant and sweat-resistant. I sweat regularly on the tip of my nose and my upper lip and I want to know if Bare Minerals looks splotchy after sweating.
EMiriamD Says:
I forgot to add La Bella Donna to my list. If I’m not mistaken this was one of the very first–if not The First–mineral makeups to arrive on the scene, probably at least ten years ago. In NYC I remember it was initially an exclusive at Takashimaya and then moved over to Bergdorf’s. Apparently it’s now only available online. It comes in loose and pressed forms, which some folks find especially convenient.
a h Says:
gloMinerals
La Bella Donna
KYredhead Says:
How about Mary Kay’s new mineral line?
* foundation
* eye & cheek colors
* highlighting & bronzing powders
* sheer pressed powder
I tried BareMinerals for a long time, too, and the MK mineral foundation gives me an airbrushed look without having to mix (ugh) or do four different steps. I use 3 or 4 light layers to cover my redness. The other stuff just came out.
KYredhead Says:
By “the other stuff,” I meant everything besides the mineral foundation (which came out last year).
david Says:
* Jane Iredale Mineral make up
* is mineral make up drying to skin or dehtdrating
Anne Says:
Spoke to a television makeup artist who says the best mineral makeup she’s used is M.A.C. - not shimmery and good colors.
kelly babbit Says:
the thing about mineral make-up that i hate is ITS SHINNY!!! MINERALS ARE SHINNY! it might be OIL FREE but there is a “GLOW” to it and i want a MATTE Look..IS there a mineral make up that gives a MATTE look?
Alex Says:
I hope I’m not too late for this! I do use bare escentuals–it’s the only time I’ve been able to wear make up that doesn’t make me break out in a sweat. But what I’m really interested in knowing more about is Colorescience–a mineral-based powdered sunscreen (also doesn’t make my face sweat). But I’m wondering how well it provides coverage and protection!
Molly Says:
Id love to know if anyone has ever tried Gourmet Body Treats stuff (ww.gourmetbodytreats.com). They have one of the lowest ratings for hazardous ingredients on http://www.cosmeticdatabase.com. I’ve been trying to find a nice natural makeup…something animal friendly and not filled with bad stuff.
I did (and still have, but am trying not to use) BareMinerals. It worked okay for me, but did make my face itchy at times. Then I read about it containing bismuth and nanoparticles and decided it might be worth it to find something a bit safer.
Amandolin Says:
I want to know about e.i.f.’s new mineral makeup. They are giving away a starter package for $20 right now. They don’t have parabens, but as I’ve been reading and have confidence in for myself, it doesn’t concern me that much. I would like to know how well it works compared to BE.
shaunajc Says:
i love neutrogena’s mineral powder, but it (and several other brands with formulations i like) stops just short of my shade…no, the bronzer is not dark enough…why the limited shade options?
Julie Says:
I have tried a few different brands. Jennifer Flavin-Stallones Serious Skin Care ProMinerals which is found on HSN and her Seriesse Skin line are pretty much one and the same. After also trying Bare Escentuals, & Bare Minerals I definitely prefer the ProMinerals and Seriesse…They offer the best coverage. Could you research all of those brands?
Jo Nielsen Says:
I have just started with Bare Escentuals and though I like the product, I wonder about it clogging pores, etc. Please research and send findings. Thanks
Suzanne Says:
Mineral makeup has worsened my skin in every way: whiteheads, blackheads, overall acne, dryness, you name it. I started out with BE, and this stuff seemed to ruin my skin slowly over time. I then switched to Signature minerals, then Suncat, but skin problems haven’t let up.
I know I had a problem with bismuth, but I am definitely also having a problem with mica, and possibly even titanium dioxide.
I just purchased samples from Beauty Bliss ( mica free) and Rejuva minerals (mica and titanium dioxide free), and am hoping these work out.
Please put these companies in your review. Thank you so much!
Christine Says:
I would be interested in comments about Cover FX mineral foundation. The original Cover FX is said to have been developed by a hospital in Toronto, Canada, as a suitable cover-up for scars etc.
skeptical hairdresser Says:
how do we know it isn’t the bare vitamins stuff that they tell us to use first that isn’t causing the problems? It made my skin feel bad so I stopped using it and just use the powder. I’ve been using bare escentuals for about a year and am thrilled. I am almost 52, and my skin is ok. just a bit wrinkled. I never smoked so it isn’t too bad. I do NOT use the bare vitamins stuff, Just a very light coating of vasaline while my face is still wet and moist from the shower, then I use the little concealer brush and put medium beige on my nose, chin and cheeks near the bridge of my nose. All the places that my roseacia shows. then I use a little warmth for a blush, or any other blush in my drawer that i spent too much on and shoved aside.Not too pink, because I think it makes old skin look too swollen. thats why I like warmth. Just a bit, and that’s it. No mineral veil, or bare vitamins or anything like that. Just vasaline, the foundation, and warmth. and a bit of eye liner. coverage is great, and it feels like nothing is on my face.
Mary Says:
I rarely use foundation, but I like Bare Minerals when I do. It seems to even out skin tone and, as long as it is applied lightly, looks as if you’re not wearing makeup. I don’t really know about the “better for your skin” claims, though. Since it seems to be just powdered pigment I suppose there’s less for bacteria to grow in, so it might be. For a mineral eye-shadow, though, I prefer Ulta’s house line. Much cheaper than other brands and yet good color and coverage.
Christa Says:
I’d like to know more about:
J Lynne Cosmetics
Everyday Minerals
Thanks!
Anna Says:
I’m curious about MyChelle Dermaceuticals’ new line of mineral cosmetics. I have recently started using their paraben-free, non-toxic, 100% natural, eco-friendly, cruelty-free skincare products to help with my acne. I’m wondering if their mineral cosmetics are just as good as the other, more commercial options on the market (B.E., Physician’s Formula, etc.). Thanks!
Fashionista Says:
I found bare escentuals 2 years ago and have been in love with it ever since… there are a few flaws with it.. but there are flaws with EVERY makeup type. I find that it is light and airy which makes you feel like you dont have anything on your face. Id recommend using a moisterizer under it if you have dryer skin. The only thing that i dislike about this product is that it is not waterproof.. at all. I mean.. i cried a couple of tears at my brothers wedding and you could see where the water touched the skin.. maybe theres a solution for that
Kay Says:
Anyone know more about Sudden Glow. I just ordered it and an wondering if I made the right choice. My skin is normal/combination.
Dee Says:
Eminence Sun Defense Minerals
Youngblood
Which guidelines will you be basing your study on?
http://www.safecosmetics.org
Thank you!
DEE DEE Says:
I am interested in information on Laura Mercier mineral make up. The sales rep claimed that they use crushed diamonds and pearls in the foundation to give it its irridescence. This makes me a bit skeptical and sounds a bit pricey to say the least.
laura keehan Says:
i’m interested in knowing how jane iredale mineral makeup compares to bare minerals
Shannon Says:
I’m curious how everyday minerals, at http://www.everydayminerals.com/g?t=home stacks up to bareminerals, and other mineral makeup.
Thanks!
Claudia Says:
I am using Laura Mercier eyeshadows and have also tried Bella Donna for eye shadows in the past but the eye shadow kept breaking so I stopped buying them. I am also using Tarte’s T5 lip gloss–are they considered mineral or just natural? Also Bare Escentuals Mineral Veil, which I LOVE.
Sandi Says:
Everyday Minerals is my favorite. I have tried BE and do not like the color selection. Signature minerals and MAD are good too. For six years I used Aromaleigh — the shipping is fantastic and colors pretty good. But the return policy is, well, there isn’t one. And, if you provide customer reviews or participate in the blog, don’t make any negative comments or they will be deleted and you will be locked out and cannot order from her anymore.
Andrea Says:
Hey Sandy, the same thing happened to me at Aromaleigh! I only commented once in the YEARS I used her products and now have been denied access. She actually deletes all negative comments on the forum. So maybe I sound disgruntled, but I disagree with Shaina, the owner does is very sensitive and easily offended. I’m on the site trying to find an alternative to Aromaleigh. I think I’ll try Everyday Minerals based on the good reviews.
MiMi Says:
I never wear foundation, and only sheer powder on special occasions…I have medium brown skin with more yellow and a bit of red, undertones. After a facial/enzyme peel…I needed something “safe” to cover the slight peeling/redness for an important function, so I started shopping for mineral makeup…After being sent to Laura Mercier(who claimed not to have anything dark enough for me) and bare ecentuals (powdered me down with ashy too lite tones for 1/2 hr. before the came to the same conclusion) I ended up buying MAC’s new mineralize powder …I’ve been using it (with my medicated cream and moisturizer/sunblock beneath it, and I LOVE the color and sheer coverage! It is a great match! They werent too sure as to the percentage of minerals in the makeup…Could you get more info on MAC mineralize, and any purer/better mineral makeup for brown skin?
Thank you!
Karla Says:
I would like to know more about Purity, Mineral Science products. Any and all information is greatly appreciated!
liz Says:
Everyday Minerals, please.
karolyn rich Says:
Thank you so much for your research into MMU. I am interested in hearing about BE, Everyday Minerals, and the drugstore brands.
Mary Owen Says:
I’d used Indian Earth in the past and liked it but just ordered some from another source recently. It was much darker and I’m not liking it. But is it OK for the skin? Thanks.
Shel Says:
I’d like to know more about Naked Minerals, please.
Jenny Says:
I have been a lot of breakouts at my face after using maybellines mineral foundation make-up.Is it an allergic reaction?what can I do?
thanks
Marlena Burger Says:
Just purchased samples of Signature Minerals. The samples were generous delivered in 3- days. 5 little pots from light to dark in your choice of colors included blusher and a translucent plus a mini ziplock of eyeshadow. Being a first time user of mineral makeup I applied to much. Second day I went light on it. It went on fine with a matte finish, you have a choice. The only drawback for me was the finish did not look or feel velvety like my liquid makeup I had been using. Next day I used my liquid makeup which I really like, believe it or not from MABELINE,called Instant Age Re-Wind(I swear they use the L’Oreal Visable Lift product with Mabeline label.)I used the Signature Minerals translucent over to set it to a matt finish. It lasted all day, very little shine by the end of the day. Still would like to find one that is velvety, matte finish and decent coverage in a sample size and I might go with the mineral make. But I am not sold on the mineral type makeups yet. Thank You.
emmy Says:
It may be a bit late, but I’ve been curious to try afterglow cosmetics : http://www.afterglowcosmetics.com/why_afterglow/. They claim to have no sensitizers, pharma-grade minerals, certified organic extracts, etc. Also it comes in lots of shades which is nice. Anyway, very curious to see the results of this project - the number of mineral make-ups available now is staggering!
Elsa Says:
I’m delighted you’re tackling this subject? I’ve been increasingly curious about mineral-powder foundations, but I’ve wondered:
- will it work for someone who wants light coverage? I’ve seen a few clips from infomercials, and they all show how to apply quite heavy coverage. Very effective, but not my style.
- is there a trick to applying it smoothly?
- does it require a specialized brush? Does the material matter, i.e., animal bristles or manmade bristles?
- will the powder emphasize the imperfections of older skin?
I’m especially interested in Everyday Minerals because they offer such a wide range of shades, but I also found the wide range a little confounding. Any tips on choosing the right shade from their tiny palettes, given the wide varieations in computer monitors?
Karie Says:
I would like to know about http://www.mineralsilk.com
They have some testominials that rave about there makeup compared to Bare Minerals. How do we choose one over the other? I dont always like to go by price but, how do we compare which is better than the other?
saf Says:
I use Lilly Lolo stuff. They have a website and they’re stuff seems to be great to me..
Paulette Says:
I thought Bare Minerals (Bare Escentuals) was the original and all the others were copied after that formula. Bare minerals is quality, and has done my skin good. Less breakouts, etc. But you HAVE to go SPARINGLY with the stuff or it will look cakey. Sparingly is all you need, if you use spot cover underneath(the bisque). I use the rare minerals (which I got on ebay at a discount) sometimes in the summer without makeup. I like it on my body rather than on my face. Go figure!
Heather Says:
Physician’s Formula and True… Love True, but when feeling cheap or while traveling Physician’s Formula from the drugstore works in a pinch. Prefer True, but it is pricy can be had to get, also love the True skin care products
Amy Says:
I use ColoureScience mineral makeup and would like to know more about it. The one I use is a pressed powder and I’d be interested to know if there are any major differences between pressed mineral powders and loose mineral powders in terms of ingredients, concentrations, and sun protection. Also I have heard reports that micronized minerals are inherently carcinogenic. Is there any science behind this claim? And if so, I’d like to know what brands micronize their mineral ingredients. If its not too much to ask!
donnarae Says:
what about vitamineral aromatherapy makeup, i acutually love it donnarae
donnarae Says:
tell me what you think about vitamineral aromatherapy makeup donna
miriam Says:
I’ve been using bare minerals/escentuals for about three years now, but walking through the malls there are mineral make up kiosks using the name “bella terra cosmetics”. Their consultants say that not only does THEIR product NOT have an expiration date, but there is an ingredient in bare minerals/escentuals that is damaging, but they couldn’t remember the name of it. I’m a bit skeptical.. I’d like to see if this is really a quality product as they make it seem.. PLEASE add to your list of investigations!!!
Thank you!
Dawnne Says:
With so many companies hopping on the minerals bandwagon, it’s hard to know just which ones are truly “all natural.” Most recently, I’ve used Bare Escentuals, but got tired of having to use Mineral Veil to cut down the shine. Two steps is one too many. Philosophy’s loose mineral product probably isn’t all natural but I’d like to know how it stacks up against all of those products that claim to be all natural but have some dubious and/or unnecessary fillers. Thanks!
Dawnne Says:
One other thing, I just received a package of minerals from European Bare Minerals. I haven’t tried them yet but they have many, many products on eBay. I was wondering how their products stack up as well, as they claim to not use Bismuth or Talc, and still have the spf 15. Any comments on European Bare Minerals?
Dawn Says:
I use TRUE Cosmetics mineral makeup. Please research this brand as well in your study.
Leana Says:
I would like to know more about Bare Minerals foundations…I tried the clear Rare Minerals Skin revival and I didn’t notice any change in my skin
kathy Says:
Definately Dr. Hauschka and Jane Irendale. How long does it last?
Samantha Says:
I wanted to know which brands of mineral makeup contain bismuth oxychloride ,which tends to make the skin itch ( especially in warm weather!). I worked briefly for the company Afterglow cosmetics (www.afterglowcosmetics.com) and they do not have bismuth oxychloride and is claimed to use certified organic ingredients such as grapeseed. I really enjoyed their line ( foundations go on creamy and do not look dry) as well as their wide variety of colors with yellow undertones ( as opposed to bare escentuals that tend to have more red undertones - has anyone seen the warmth and the deep shades?)but I wanted to know if there was other brands out there similar or better. I also wanted to know more about the different brushes. Each line has different types of hairs which claim to pick up the powders better but to be quite honest I feel that its not really the hairs but the packing of the brushes that gives the right application. For example, the kabuki brush from bare escentuals has sable hairs that are packed tightly together to give full coverage, but if you were to use say, Sephora’s, Nars,Smashbox’s bronzer brush you would get pretty much the same coverage. Also, does it matter if the hairs are natural or synthetic. I know that synthetic hairs tend to be better for creams or liquids but for those who prefer a vegan approach I was wondering if there were any good lines that don’t use hairs from animals ( Besides, afterglow cosmetics which use taklon). Well I think I’ve rambled enough. Thank you.
Vicky S Says:
Hi,
I’ve heard about Peter Thomas Roth Instant Mineral SPF 30 but I’m not sure how effective this is as a sunblock?
If it’s mineral won’t it come off really easily? I currently use Avene tinted compact sunblock with an SPF of 50 but I have a feeling its going to be very heavy in the summer.
Bay Area Says:
I want to thank you for doing such a in-depth investigation. I am looking very forward to it. I am hoping to see a table that compares prices, spf, purity (no additives,no talc, or that stuff that people say makes them itch), coverage (how well it covers, matte/sparkly),an overall rating.
I would also like to know the definitions of mineral vocab, important ingredients that we should look out for whether good or bad for skin. Also, does it matter what brand of brush we use. If we buy mineral makeup from a certain company do we have to buy their brushes. Also, I bought the Rare Minerals renew and reveal facial cleanser from Bare Escentuals. Its a powder. I would like to know if there is really any benefit from using this specific cleanse. I also bought the Rare Minerals skin revival treatment (night)and the Rare Minerals acne treatment from BE are they really beneficial to my skin? Does the night treatment really work? What about the acne treatment? Thank you so much!
tlk Says:
What about Sheer cover? How does it stack up to the other brands. I find that it does not cover as well as they advertise. Is it worth the increased price over Revlon/Maybelline/L’oreal mineral powder foundations?
Stevie Says:
I’ve used two types of mineral make-up (NAO - Never Accept Ordinary and Artistry Essentials) and have liked them a lot. I would definitely like more info on it such as coverage, how good it really is for your skin, skin protection, so on and so forth.
Can’t wait to see what you come up with!
jane Says:
I am sold on Mineral Essence. I’ve tried them all. Avon is horrid !. I am a derm patient for rosacea and skin cancer. I love Mineral Essence. Coverage ! The moment of truth came when my dermatologist said “What ever you are doing, keep doing it!” When I told him what I was using he encouraged that all woman should use 100% mineral makeup.
Roxanna Says:
I would like to know more about the Shaklee brand named Minerelles. I like them a lot but would be curious to know how you find them in testing.
Alexis Says:
I would just love a recommendation. I would like to know what mineral foudation can actually (realistically) do for skin, and if you ahve fairly normal / dry skin which brand would be best. Also, is talc bad in foundation? I have no idea! Thanks xxx
Bren Says:
I use Isadora mineral foundation, blush, eyeshadows and compact powder. My usually sensitive skin has shown no adverse reactions, which is great. Following the hype around nano-particle size I did email them one day, enquiring about the particle size in their products, receiving no reply whatsoever. So even though my experience with the stuff is good, that doesn’t exactly encourage my loyalty to Isadora as a brand.
Martine Says:
I have been using various differnt brands of mineral over the past few years and by far have found Susan Posnick Mineral Make-up to be of the highest quality. My skin has improved dramatically, it contains an SPF 26 and comes in a refillable self dispensing brush, unlike others which spill every where. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
Ying Says:
I’ve used BE and it’s pretty good so far, but the only problem I have with it is it does rub off, and you see it especially if you wear white.
I’m interested in Lotus Minerlas, which I’ve heard great reviews about, plus they give you free samples before you buy! I’m going to give that a try.
Ginni Says:
Everyday Minerals and RAW Natural Minerals
Pas71 Says:
I really like Milani’s mineral foundation even though the packaging and brush are absolutely horrible. It’s SOOOO much better than the Neutrogena one I tried, which was more like a pressed powder. The Milani one (which is cheap, too!) goes on and looks great.
Ann Jones Says:
I love my Mary Kay Mineral Powder Foundation….flawless, natural look and ease of application! And the mineral eye and cheek colors, mineral highlighters and mineral bronzers are wonderful!!! Mary Kay has my vote!
EMiriamD Says:
In case these haven’t been mentioned already, I’d like to hear your opinion of the mineral foundations offered by Meow Cosmetics and Lauren Hutton.
Thanks!
paula Says:
I tried Bare Minerals and it made my face very oily. After trying different types of products from Bare Minerals to try to correct the problem, I ended up shipping back the product for a full refund. I went back to Physicians Formula, which I love.
Thanks, PJ
Leola Robinson Says:
What information do you have on Market America’s Motives Hydrating Mineral Powders?
Saira Says:
i would like to know more about Loreal bare minerals… i’m currently using it and like its coverage on my face but still i like to more about it.
Dorina Says:
I’ve used Neutrogena and while it was okay on my skin - it didn’t last. My oily skin as with other foundations would wipe off with a touch of my finger. In my 40s with redness on my cheeks, was hoping to find something to last 8 hours at least.
Have been hopping sites and found everyone’s comments very useful. But no one mentioned E.L.F. (Eyes Lips Face) which compares itself to high end cosmetics and is available online. I have seen it mentioned in many magazine beauty editor articles.
Bascially, looking forward to reading what you guys come up with and thank you!
Bonnie Says:
Thank you, Thank you for doing something on mineral makeup. I love mineral makup but I wonder if the claims are true. I’ve used Bare Escentials and Sheer Cover, Avon, and there’s a few over the counter ones too. So far I like Bare Escentials best, but it is so expensive that now I am using Avon. It’s ok, just a little grainy, not as smooth as the other brands.
I feel I need more information on the subject and more alternatives. Please include these products in your report.
Thank you, Bonnie
Zhariel Says:
So far I’ve tried Revlon Mineral Foundation, Everyday Minerals in Cool-Fair Original Glo and Cool-Fair Semi-Matte (the semi-matte caused me to break out which surprised me), and Buff-Ivory Original Glo. I’ve ordered Inquisitive Chausie in Purrrfect Puss from Meow Cosmetics to try it out. I also just ordered samples of AromaLeigh Mineral Makeup in Alabaster Glissade (G-00) and Ivory Glissade (G-1CL). I’d love to see you review Meow Cosmetics, AromaLeigh Cosmetics and Everyday Minerals.
Eliza Says:
I love mineral makeup and would like to know more about bareFaced minerals.
I’m looking forward to reading your report. Thank you for doing this.
Kim Says:
I had been using BE for about 5 years when I found Dash Minerals. I compared the quality and the price, and I became such a believer in the purity and quality of Dash, that I became a consultant for them. Dash Minerals do not contain parabens or bismuth oxychloride. My 16 year old daughter’s face cleared up within a month. Icing on the cake is that Dash is less than 1/2 the price of BE, and even less than most drug store brands while selling a top quality product. Really… give Dash a try.
Aeona Heart Says:
I love Skinfully Bare Minerals! They really care about what goes into their products. They also have stuff on their site all about the facts that other companies dont want you to know about. I believe them when they say their makeup is healthy for you. I got the foundation & it’s only got 4 ingredients in it! It covers everything so I don’t need concealer now. It’s really cheap to buy so you can get more than you do of other brands.
Colette Says:
please compare bare essentuals minerals makeup, avon ideal shade smooth mineral makeup, laura mercier mineral makeup and the drugstore brands.
Kelsey Says:
Everyday Minerals
Signature Minerals
Radiant Minerals - radiantminerals.com
The third is a very small home business. I’d look into that…especially since the eyeshadows have such fabulous colors!
Jenny Says:
I was wondering if you can check Everyday Minerals. Thanks!
Inge Says:
how about mineralogie?
Jenn Says:
I’m interested in Colorescience line of mineral sunscreen/sun protection. Some of them are tinted. Thanks!
Linda Says:
Bare Escentuals
This is the only makeup I use now. I am almost 50 years old and I finally have makeup that I like!
Rebecca Says:
My favorite foundation, concealer and blush is Everyday Minerals. I’m new to mineral makeup and just fell in love with EDM. I like maximum matte coverage and never thought a mineral makeup would work. I was wrong. I haven’t liked my makeup so much in 15 years. I love EDM for their product and price!
I also sampled Ocean Mist, Meow Cosmetics, Bare Escentuals and Avon’s new line. Ocean Mist is a close second on product and price to EDM. I LOVE Ocean Mist’s Silken Perfection. It is comparable to BE’s mineral veil, but I think it is finer — also better priced. BE was too shiny for me and accentuated my flaws. My Meow samples were all too grey, but they have many shades, so it isn’t necessarily their fault. I did like their texture and matteness. I also got some great samples of eyeshadows from Meow. I’m definately a fan of Meow. Avon’s foundation did not seem as fine and had a talc smell to it. Seemed subpar to me, but not awful. Avon’s mineral blush and eyeshadows were okay as well at a decent price.
Rebecca Says:
I wanted to add that I didn’t realize what liquid foundation was doing to my skin. In 3 weeks of using Everyday Minerals, my skin is less oily, haven’t had a real blemish, less blackheads and my pores are reduced. I wish I’d turned to mineral makeups a long time ago.
Nena Says:
I was wondering if you could include Bella Pierre mineral makeup in your review. Thankyou!
Lin Says:
Lily Lolo is currently my favourite brand of mineral makeup and I’m interested in reading rewiews/info about it, compared to other brands.
I have also tried Bare Escentuals but I find it too “sparkly” for use outdoors in the sunlight. It looks good in artificial light though, so now I use Bare Escentuals when i go out nighttime and Lily Lolo for a radiant natural daytime look.
I only apply a small amount of mineral foundation because I want a natural looking result, will it still act as a sunscreen (spf15) or does that require a thick layer of foundation?
Risa Says:
Since everyone says theirs is the best, I’m curious to know about Jane Iredale (I know makeup artists that swear by it) but even more about Minerologie. JI is the most expensive, but it seems that once you cross that line of those who leave out the ‘crap’ and get into the more carefully created brands, the price goes up but they are within a few dollars of each other. So, I am just interested in knowing what’s worth it and what isn’t. Thanks!
Jennifer Says:
I’ve tried Jane Iredale, Bare Minerals and Larenim. JI is quite expensive, but I loved the color match. BM worked just as well, little less expensive, but I had to purchase 2 colors to blend for the perfect color match. Larenim does not contain bismuth, which is why I tried it. Unfortunately, the coverage was very minimal. The girl at the makeup counter at Whole Foods where I purchased it told me that this was due to not having bismuth (which gives it better adherence to your skin). Of all these, I preferred JI. I first used JI because I have melasma and the coverage was great and very natural.
Amy Says:
Here’s another vote for an Aromaleigh review. I love their extensive list of foundation options, though I know they tend towards the paler colors. I also like the Aromaleigh Rocks! Sonic products, though I know think they are admittedly non as “pure” a mineral make up in order to get the great pigments.
Monave is another line I’d like to hear about, as it’s local to me. I tried it and found it to be a bit drying (I have oily but flaky skin) but they have a great line of colors, for darker skin too.
Kristiina Says:
I just started using Erth Minerals last week…I’m also using their ‘organic’ cleansing and moistrurising line…love the makeup minerals, but on the fence w/the paraben free lotion. thanks!
http://www.lushbrush.com
TRISH Says:
I’ve been using BE but am concerned with the bismuth, titaium dioxide and iron oxides. BE Mineral Veil is corn starch,expensive (could have used what I had in the kitchen) and makes me itch when I perspire on my face (hot flashes). Ordered samples of Alima Cosmetics and Earth’s Beauty. Q: Does arrowroot and cornsilk give much coverage? Are cornsilk and cornstarch the same ingredient? Thanks for your help… Trish
Iris Says:
I am curious about Bare Minerals Blemish Therapy foundation…. also, Neutrogena mineral powder ( the kind in the brush that you shake and apply).
Thanks!!
tsarina Says:
Melaleuca recently came out with Mineral makeup products under the Nicole Miller brand. Do you have any insight on those? Thanks!